Wednesday, May 02, 2007

Search or Experience, But Not Both

Recently, I had the idea to perform a test that truly tested the relevance of the search results themselves; on Google, Yahoo! and MSN. My thought was this; when you look at the results themselves, they are not that different, so why does Google have nearly 64% of the search market share (according to Hitwise) where MSN sits in a distant third with less than 9%?

Is there something we’re not considering here?

Does Google just make it easier to do what you need to get done?

I think the answer to both of these questions is yes. There are some things that we’re not considering here, and having a background in graphic design made it easy for me to have an affinity for what’s being missed. As Marissa Mayer will admit, Google is very focused on the end user quite passionately and I’m sure that a part of that market share can be attributed directly to that fact, and maybe more than just a part.

The gist of our study involved a single page of results on paper from each of the big three engines using the same keyphrase, in this instance we chose “digital camera”. We passed this around a small sample of people and had them choose what they felt the top 3 most relevant results were out of the entire list, not on each page.

Not only were the results surprising, but they were completely backwards from what we and every other search marketer would have expected.

When we scored the results (3 points for 1st choice, 2 points for 2nd choice and 1 point for 3rd), MSN came out as having far and away the most relevant results. The margin was not just a 10% or 15% margin, MSN was more than 3 times as successful as Google in terms of its relevance. And when measured against Yahoo, MSN outperformed those results as well, doubling Yahoo’s relevance score.

It seems that Google is doing many of the other things right in order for their relevance to be perceived as well as it has been. Their Progressive Disclosure model has allowed them to keep the interface clean and their users well taken care of, as the Google tools they need only show up when they need them.

Basic design principles are adhered to on the results page and, as much as people mock the simplicity of the homepage, there are more benefits to it than looking clean and tidy. This “clean and tidy” homepage also keeps the user’s mindframe “clean and tidy” or more focused if you prefer. There are less distractions to a user’s focus when compared to the portal page for either Yahoo or MSN.

This is proven through our Eye Tracking 2 whitepaper. When you compare the condensed pattern on Google results pages against the spread out activity on the busy portal pages, it displays obvious remnants of distraction. And when you consider that short
-term memory has a forward memory span of approximately seven items plus or minus two (Miller, 1956), those distractions are doing more to detrimentally affect the pure search experience by filling our little short-term memories with news, pictures, ads and information… All of which have nothing to do with what we’re searching for.

So, MSN may have the most relevant results (according to our little panel), but it turns out that it’s more important to do the rest of the search experience up right. Which begs another bit of insight; it seems that in the phrase, search experience, the word that we would expect to be the most important often isn’t.

So MSN, or Windows Live Search as you are trying to be referred to as, if you want to put a cork in the leaky dam of market share, put more experience into the search experience.

15 comments:

jennyp234 said...

I think its all about brand recognition. People don't search for anything anymore they Google (not MSN or Yahoo! it) it. They don’t buy tissues, they buy Kleenex. Even if a competitor of Kleenex comes out with a far superior product, Kleenex has the advantage with the name they have made for themselves and the company history.

Dhiya L said...

wow really superb you had posted one nice information through this. Definitely it will be useful for many people. So please keep update like this.

Java Training in Chennai

Abiya Carol said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Abiya Carol said...

Such a great articles in my carrier, It's wonderful commands like easiest understand words of knowledge in information's.

Branding Services in Chennai

Shaakshi said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Shaakshi said...

Thank you for taking the time to discuss this informative content with us. I feel happy about the topic that you have shared with us. keep sharing your information regularly for my future reference. This content creates a new hope and inspiration with me. Thanks for sharing article. The way you have stated everything above is quite awesome. Keep blogging like this. Thanks.
Car Cleaning at Doorstep in Mumbai

Padhma said...

this article was superb,but i expecting more information from this topic.but its useful

Back to original

Shalini said...

This is an awesome post.Really very informative and creative contents. These concept is a good way to enhance the knowledge.I like it and help me to development very well.Thank you for this brief explanation and very nice information.Well, got a good knowledge.

digital marketing company in india

Mahalya sree said...

I really liked this part of the article, with a nice and interesting topics have helped a lot of people who do not challenge things people should know... you need more publicize this so many people who know about it are rare for people to know this......
Best Interior Designers in Chennai
Interior Designers in Chennai

Lunameadow said...

This is extremely great information for these blog!! And Very good work. It is very interesting to learn from to easy understood. Thank you for giving information. Please let us know and more information get post to link.

Oracle Training in Chennai

Philips Huges said...

Its a wonderful post and very helpful, thanks for all this information. You are including better information regarding this topic in an effective way.Thank you so much

Personal Installment Loans
Title Car loan
Cash Advance Loan

sandhosh said...

Good blog post which provided a interesting information.keep updating...
SEO Company in India
SEO Services in India
SEO Companies in India
SEO Company India
SEO Services India

Aashi siva said...

Great Article… I love to read your articles because your writing style is too good, its is very very helpful for all of us

Vmware Training in Chennai

Web Designing Training in Chennai

AWS Training in Chennai

Linux Training in Chennai

Microsoft Azure Training in Chennai

sreenu usha said...

There will always be winners and losers, and I think many of these probably do have quite a diverse range of material, with a common thread running through them. This is how I think of Oracle Code, a diverse collection of subjects loosely woven together by an Oracle thread.
Oracle SQL/PLSQL course

sivasurya rg said...

BIG DATA Technologies provides you with a state of the art software which combines modern GPU technology (Graphic Processing Units) with the best practices in today’s Big Data platforms, providing up to 100x faster insights from data.
Bigdata Training in Chennai OMR